Sustainable funds see $5.2bn outflows in Q1

'It's hard to ignore impact of political backlash against sustainable investing'

Investors pulled $5.2bn from US sustainable funds in Q1, the third quarter of outflows in a year, according to Morningstar’s Global Sustainable Fund Flows: Q1 2023 in Review report.

A total of $12.4bn has exited these funds over the past year amid challenging market conditions and growing anti-ESG rhetoric – Republican governors from at least 19 US states have pledged to resist ESG investing over “antitrust, consumer protection and discrimination concerns”, Morningstar noted.

“In the US, besides the challenging market environment, another factor that could have contributed to the third quarterly outflow in a year is the political backlash against sustainable investing. While it’s hard to measure its impact on investor demand for ESG products, it is equally hard to ignore it,” commented Hortense Bioy (pictured), global director of sustainability at Morningstar.

Unlike in Europe where passives gained 75% of new flows, active funds were in favour in the US in Q1 breaking a three-quarter streak of outflows; they netted $91m, while passive mandates shed nearly $6.1bn. However, the report said: “If not for one fund, namely iShares ESG Aware MSCI USA ETF ESGU, which bled nearly $6.5bn, passive funds would have ended the quarter in the black.”

Bond funds were also popular with $500m in inflows, compared with equity funds, which lost $5.4bn of outflows.

Rising equity and bond markets, however, meant overall assets were higher reaching $296bn – their highest point in a year.

In terms of product launches, this also slowed in the US with 17 new funds coming to market – down from 44 in Q4 2022.

US sustainable fund flows by asset class ($bn)

US sustainable fund flows by asset class (US$bn)
Source: Morningstar Direct. Manager Research. Data as of March 2023


Looking at the sustainable fund universe from a global perspective, inflows stood at $29bn for the first quarter of 2023, down from $38bn the previous quarter. The report said investor sentiment was dampened by “macroeconomic pressures including rising interest rates, inflation and a looming recession”. However, like in Europe, higher valuations meant fund assets rose to $2.74trn from the restated $2.55trn in the previous quarter.

“This 7.5% expansion exceeds the overall global fund market growth of 4% in the three months through March 2023,” the report said.

Bioy commented: “The first quarter was a continuation of what we saw in 2022. ESG funds are not immune to the challenging macro environment, as reflected by their lower inflows compared with a few quarters ago. But ESG funds are still growing faster than the broader fund market, supported by increased ESG regulation at both company-and fund-level.”


Inflows and product development in European sustainable funds slowed in Q1 2023 but assets under managements nudged towards historical highs, according to data from Morningstar.

The report showed net flows into the European sustainable fund universe declined to $32.3bn in the first quarter of 2023 from the readjusted $40.3bn of the previous quarter.

Passives were popular taking three quarters of the new capital. In terms of asset classes, equity strategies took the lion’s share of the inflows with almost $21bn, while sustainable bond funds gathered only $12.6bn, which is much less than the $19.2bn in the previous quarter.

Sustainable fund flows compared with conventional fund flows by asset class

Sustainable fund flows compared with conventional fund flows by asset class

Despite the lower flows, Morningstar reported assets in strategies rising for the second-consecutive quarter to reach $2.3trn, up 8.2% from December 2022 due to higher valuations. As a result, the market share of sustainable funds in Europe rose to 22% from 18%.

However, the number of new launches within sustainable funds also slowed to a historical low of 53 – this is compared with 155 in Q4 2022.

“The decline in new products can be partly attributed to the overall market sentiment damped by the challenging macro backdrop but also to greenwashing accusations and the ever-evolving regulatory environment,” the report said.

“A clarification by ESMA last summer led many product manufacturers to downgrade Article 9 funds to Article 8 funds in the second part of the year, while waiting for further guidance on fund classification and how to interpret the definition of a ‘sustainable investment’ provided by Article 2 of the EU’s Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation.

Asia, Japan and Australia

Looking at data excluding China, the Asia region saw investors pull $97m with thematic equity funds investing in secondary batteries and electric car manufacturers driving the outflows. Meanwhile, fixed income strategies experienced inflows.

South Korea had the highest outflows of $545m, while Singapore and Hong Kong saw outflows of $157m and $117m respectively. By contrast, Taiwan experienced the largest net inflows at $710m, while Malaysia saw the second-most net inflows at $49m.

Akin to the other regions, assets climbed 3.1% to $63bn by the end of March. Taiwan and South Korea remain the largest markets accounting for 17% and 11.6% of the region’s assets respectively.

There were 26 new launches across the Asia region 17 of which were from China. Allocation and equity funds comprised the bulk of new launches.

Asia ex-Japan sustainable fund flows by asset class (US$bn)

Asian sustainable fund flows by asset class (US$bn)
Source: Morningstar Direct, Manager Research. Data as of March 2023

Japan also saw net outflows – the third consecutive quarter – of $961m. Morningstar commented: “In Japan, newly launched funds tend to attract inflows, but within a few years after inception, investors take their money out. The decrease in newly launched ESG funds in the first quarter meant that inflows into newer funds couldn’t offset the outflows from older funds. Notably, eight out of top 10 funds in terms of outflows were launched in either 2020 or 2021.” Only two new funds were launched in Q1. Meanwhile, assets increased 3% in the region to $26bn due to higher stock prices.

In Australia and New Zealand, sustainable funds flows were dramatically lower than previous periods; inflows amounted to $108m down from $1.53bn in Q4 2023. Assets increased by 7.8% to $30.8bn.


Natalie Kenway

Natalie is editor in chief at MA Financial covering ESG Clarity, Portfolio Adviser and International Adviser. She was previously global head of ESG insight for ESG Clarity and has been an investment journalist...